Best Mattress To Buy Online:10 Options For Different Needs

Photo of author

This post may contain affiliate links, and we will be compensated if you buy after clicking on our links.

Spoiler alert: the Avocado Green mattress is overall the best mattress to buy online.

Consumer Reports Recommends
Avocado Green Mattress
  • Naturally Resilient And High Performing Latex Comfort Layer
  • Zoned Pocket Coil Core
  • Rated 7 Out Of 10 On Firmness Scale 
  • Made In USA With Hand Crafted Finishing Touches
  • Massive 1 YEAR Sleep Trial
  • 25 Year Warranty
  • Organic Materials And Carbon Neutral Manufacturing

What’s the best mattress to buy online? Are you struggling to choose a great mattress, with so many options out there? Is everything mattress starting to look the same to you? Maybe you’re looking for one particular feature, like advanced cooling, and you just can’t tell which one is going to work well. I’m here to help you! While I don’t believe there is one best mattress to buy online (we are all different, so there can’t be a one size fits all) I do believe there is a best mattress for different scenarios.

In this article I’ll take you through my recommendations for the best:

  • Cooling Mattress
  • Luxury Mattress
  • Budget Mattress
  • Organic Mattress
  • Best For Heavy People
  • Best For Light People
  • The Best Online Mattress Range

I’ll tell you why I think they’re the best for each scenario, give you the lowdown on sleep trials, warranties and prices, and link you to my detailed reviews for each.

I’ll also reveal which one out of all these I’d buy myself, at the end of the article.

If you’re one of my New Zealand readers, click here to read about the NZ online mattress I like the best.

These Are The Best Mattresses To Buy Online

Best For Cooling

Best Mattress To Buy Online For Cooling - Aurora

The Aurora mattress by Brooklyn Bedding has to be my first choice of hybrid mattresses for cooling.

It features a cooling top panel (which you would have to pay extra for on other mattresses) and two layers of cooling foams in the comfort layers. The fact that it’s a hybrid means that air flows easily through the base of the mattress to help get rid of excess heat.

Available in soft, medium, or firm (the medium is the most popular), there’s an Aurora option to suit everyone.

Click Here For A Detailed Aurora Review

Best Mattress To Buy Online For Cooling : GhostBeds

Hybrid mattresses may have a better reputation for cooling because air can flow around the coils, but GhostBeds have made an all foam mattress that is more than capable of doing the job.

Featuring their patented “Ghost Ice” fabric both in the cover of the mattress and as a layer on top of the memory foam, the GhostBed Luxe works hard to draw body heat away and out of the mattress. Ghost Ice is a phase change material, which means it changes its state in response to body heat, working to keep you cool.

That’s not the only cooling feature inside your GhostBed Luxe mattress though: you’ve also got two cooling foams inside the mattress. Overall, it’s pretty hard to disagree with them when they say this is “the coolest bed in the world.”

Click Here For A Detailed GhostBed Luxe Review

Best Luxury

Best Luxury Hybrid

When I think about luxury mattresses, Saatva pops into my head every time. This mattress has so many standout features it’s hard to know where to start.

First up, it’s not a mattress in a box. Your Saatva will be delivered with white glove delivery, set up, and removal of your old mattress all at no extra cost. This is a service you would pay hundreds for elsewhere.

Second, it features a double coil system: it has a layer of micro pocket coils in comfort layer, and a strong innerspring support unit. I don’t know if you’ve ever tried a double coil mattress, but I used to own one (that cost a lot more than Saatva) and it was the comfiest mattress I’ve ever had in my life.

Saatva also has a unique lumbar support wire through the middle of the mattress, which is a feature I’ve not seen anywhere else.

So if you’re looking for a luxury mattress with a difference, Saatva is the right choice for you.

Click Here For A Detailed Saatva Classic Review

Best Luxury Foam - Puffy Royal

The Puffy Royal is the most recent addition to the extremely popular Puffy mattress range. This mattress was first available as an all foam mattress (as shown here), but Puffy have recently added a hybrid option. They’re one of the few companies where you can choose if you want a hybrid or all foam version of the same mattress, so this is great to see.

Packed full of features like extra foam layers, specialized airflow, zoned support foam and a premium cover, it really stands out from the other Puffy mattresses (the Puffy and Puffy Lux).

It’s priced more than the other two Puffy mattresses for obvious reasons, but I think it actually represents the best value for money given what you’re getting when you buy your Puffy Royal.

Click Here For A Detailed Puffy Royal Review

Best Budget

Best Budget Hybrid

The Lucid Memory Foam Hybrid is such good value for money it’s almost a little bit hard to believe.

Featuring innovative foams infused with charcoal and aloe vera to keep your mattress fresh, it also has a foam encasing around the pocket coil base. This is something you often only see on mattresses that cost 3-4 times the price of this Lucid mattress.

Furthermore, they’re one of the only companies in this price bracket that will offer you a 100 night sleep trial, which makes it even easier for you to buy this budget priced beauty.

Click Here For More On Budget Hybrids On Amazon

Best Matteress To Buy Online: Budget Foam

The Zinus Green Tea is probably the most popular budget memory foam mattress in the United States. It’s constantly at the top of the Amazon Best Seller rankings, with thousands of happy customers.

Zinus is excellent value for money: they pack a lot of features into their budget priced mattresses such as charcoal and green tea infusions, and cooling channels to help manage your body heat. I can tell you right now that similarly priced memory foam mattresses often don’t offer even half the features that Zinus does, so it’s easy to see why it’s so popular.

Click Here For A Detailed Zinus Green Tea Review

Best Organic

Best Organic Mattress - Avocado Green

Avocado Green has to be one of my all-time favorite mattresses. Their all organic materials and eco friendly approach to manufacturing are streets ahead of their competition. They also feature some of the nicest quality mattresses on the market with hand finished features like button tufting on the cover.

The most popular Avocado Green mattress is their hybrid, which contains zoned pocket coils, organic latex, organic wool, and organic cotton. If you’re looking for an all latex mattress, they have also just launched a brand new 100% organic latex mattress, which is excellent value for money.

Not only is Avocado one of the best quality mattresses you can buy online, they also have excellent customer service. They are a company you’ll feel really good about buying from.

Click Here For A Detailed Avocado Green Review

Best Mattress To Buy Online For Heavy People

Best Mattress To Buy Online For Heavy People - WinkBed Plus

If you weigh 230lb or more, you’re going to want a mattress that is built specifically with you in mind. You want to know you’re buying something that can give you the support and comfort you deserve, without having to worry about whether the mattress is going to be too soft or not durable.

The WinkBed Plus is absolutely jam packed with features that have been carefully build around your exact requirements, and I think you’ll find it hard to beat the value for money you get when you invest in WinkBeds.

Regularly awarded with accolades such as best overall mattress, WinkBeds is an extremely popular choice that’s difficult to look past.

Click Here For More On Memory Foam Mattresses For Heavy People

Best Mattress To Buy Online For Lighter People

Best For Light People - Layla

Lighter people need a mattress with some softness in it so you can actually feel like you are getting some pressure relief from the foams. Layla is an excellent choice for you because it’s got the best of both worlds if you’re feeling worried about buying a “soft mattress”: it has a soft side AND a firm side.

An all foam mattress, it features memory foam on both sides and a firm polyfoam core. The different feel on each side of the mattress is achieved through changing the thickness of the memory foam layer.

The softer side has a thick layer of copper gel infused memory foam for great contouring and cooling, and should provide the perfect balance of support and comfort if you’re around 130lb or less.

Click Here For A Detailed Layla Review

Best Mattress Range

Best Mattress Range - Helix

Helix is an incredibly popular mattress brand that has long recognized the fact that not one size fits all. They have quite a few mattresses in their range, but once you understand how they’ve classified them, it’s easy to find the one that’s right for you.

First, decide if you want soft, medium, or firm. Then, decide if you want side sleeper support (contouring foams for deeper pressure relief around the shoulders) or back and stomach sleeper support (faster response foam for less sinkage). Then, you’ll know exactly what Helix mattress is right for you. You can also choose between the standard models and the Luxe models, which feature some beautiful upgrades.

Don’t worry if it sounds hard to decide which one to pick, click the link above to let the Helix sleep quiz find your perfect match. I’ve tested this quiz with a few different people in mind, and the answers have been spot on every time.

Click Here For A Detailed Review Of Helix’s Top Seller

Editor’s Opinion: THE Best Mattress To Buy Online IS:

It’s a tie! I’d buy either the Saatva, or the Avocado Green mattress.

Why these two?

Well, with Saatva, I really like the double coil system. As I said above, I think this is one of the most comfortable designs around. The high quality construction and long sleep trial seal the deal.

The fact that Saatva is also one of the few online mattresses that doesn’t come in a box will also be reassuring for you if you’re wanting to buy a mattress on the internet but just can’t get your head around the idea of it arriving compacted in a box!

Avocado Green is one of my favorite mattresses, and I’ve included it in many “best of” lists, because it’s really hard to beat. I love the organic materials and the eco-conscious ethos of the company. It is slightly on the firmer side though, so as someone who falls asleep on their side I’d invest in adding either the pillow top or their soft topper to my Avocado purchase.


Emily Johnstone

Emily is the creator and owner of Emily's scientific background gives her an analytical, critical, and discerning eye to bring unbiased, thorough, and helpful content to the site. Your good sleep is her top priority. Find out more about Emily and here.