Extra Firm Mattress Toppers: Top 3 To Firm Your Bed Up Straight Away

Photo of author

This post may contain affiliate links, and we will be compensated if you buy after clicking on our links.

Looking for extra firm mattress toppers to transform your current mattress? I’ve got three of the absolute best extra firm mattress topper options on the market to share with you. All three toppers are made from natural (or organic) latex, which is known for its resiliency and durability. Win! There’s only one that’s actually marketed as extra firm, so I think if firmness is your absolute top priority for your new topper, I’ve got you sorted with my top choice.

  1. Firmest of them all: PlushBeds Natural Latex Topper
  2. Best luxury firm topper: Avocado Green Latex Topper
  3. Best budget firm topper: Pure Green Latex Topper

1. Firmest Mattress Topper Available: PlushBeds

PlushBeds Natural Latex Topper

The PlushBeds mattress topper takes out the prize for the firmest in this review, and is the only company I’ve seen offering an “extra firm” option. It’s made of natural latex and is also my top recommendation for people with back pain. Organic latex like that used in the Avocado mattress topper above is the highest grade, but you can still rest assured knowing you’re buying a beautiful quality, healthy product when you buy a mattress topper from PlushBeds.

The PlushBeds topper is not as luxe as the Avocado above because it doesn’t have a cover or layer like wool inside it, but that won’t matter at all because you’ll put your bedding on top of it anyway. Please note that this topper is not returnable.

Here are the standout features:

  • You choose 2 or 3 inch height
  • Natural latex
  • 4 Firmness options: the two firmest choices are “medium firm” and “extra firm”
  • Made in the USA. Latex sourced from Sri Lanka

2. The Luxe Mattress Topper Option: Avocado Green

Extra Firm Mattress Toppers - Shop The Avocado Green Firm Mattress Topper

The Avocado Green Mattress Topper is a fantastic mattress topper. Made from 100% organic materials, it’s not only high quality but it’s also the most eco friendly and healthy. I love it so much that it features on pretty much every list I write about mattress toppers (it comes in a soft option too, so it works well for everyone).

The whopping one year sleep trial gives you ample time to try it out in your own home. Many mattress toppers don’t even have a sleep trial so this is exceptionally generous and rare.

Here are the stand-out features:

  • Organic cotton cover
  • Organic wool layer
  • 2 inches of organic latex
  • Total height 2.75 inches
  • Made in the USA with carbon negative manufacturing and shipping procedures. Latex sourced from India.

This is going to be a great firm option for lighter to average weight sleepers. The firmest topper in this review is just below:

3. Best Firm Budget Option

Pure Green Latex Mattress Topper

The Pure Green latex mattress topper by Sleep On Latex is an extremely popular topper with Amazon customers. Again featuring natural latex, this is the cheapest topper of the bunch and you’re getting excellent value for money. Again there is no cover or sleep trial, but you’ve got the biggest range of sizes here, and a very high firmness rating.

Here are the stand out features:

  • Biggest choice of depth: 1, 2, or 3 inches
  • Prices start under $100
  • Natural latex
  • Firmness rating is extra firm
  • Made in USA. Latex sourced from Sri Lanka

Extra Firm Mattress Topper FAQ:

Can A Mattress Topper Make A Bed Firmer?

Yes, definitely. As long as your mattress or its foundation is not saggy.

If the condition of your mattress and base is good but it just feels too soft, adding a firm mattress topper can totally change the feel of your bed for the better.

If your mattress is sagging or you’re using a worn out box spring, adding a mattress topper won’t help: it will just sag with the rest of your old bed. Read about some great firm mattress replacements here and some great box spring replacements here.

Do Firm Mattress Toppers Work?

Yes. A firm topper will add a dense layer of firm materials between you and your mattress, and totally change the feel of your bed.

My favorite firm mattress topper material is latex (as you will have noticed from my recommendations above), because it’s super resilient, durable, and breathable. It will give a firm surface while also giving breathability.

Should I Get A 2 Inch Or 3 Inch Topper?

This depends on your current bed.

I think that 2 inches is enough for most people. This is a good depth to change the feel of the mattress, without making it too high. It will also be cheaper.

However, if you’re looking to really change the height of your bed and drastically transform the feel, then 3 inches might be best for you. If your mattress is extremely soft, a 3 inch topper will be your best option.

What Kind Of Mattress Topper Is Firm?

As you will have noticed above, I like latex toppers. I think they make the best firm toppers because they are the most resilient material that will hold its shape for the longest time.

Memory foam can also be engineered to give a firm feel, but I think it’s hard to beat natural latex.


Emily Johnstone

Emily is the creator and owner of bestmattressforyou.com. Emily's scientific background gives her an analytical, critical, and discerning eye to bring unbiased, thorough, and helpful content to the site. Your good sleep is her top priority. Find out more about Emily and bestmattressforyou.com here.