Winkl Vs Ecosa – Which Is Right For You?
Winkl and Ecosa are two very popular mattress in a box options available here in New Zealand. In this Winkl Vs Ecosa comparison, I’ll take you through the differences of each, their construction, and help you decide which one would be best for you. I actually own an Ecosa…. if I could choose again, would I buy Winkl instead?
Here’s an overview of Winkl Vs Ecosa to get us started:
The obvious similarities are that they are both all foam mattresses made in China that have a 3 layer construction. They have similar price points and warranties. Both use good cooling technologies, which are absolutely essential to prevent an all foam mattress trapping heat through the night.
Both regularly have discounts on their products. In fact, you can pretty much ignore RRP for mattresses in boxes, you’ll never pay it.
There’s a lot more to it than that though. That’s about where the similarities end, as these mattresses are actually quite different to each other.
There are many differences between the two mattresses, here are the key ones to note:
- Winkl is NZ owned, Ecosa is Australian owned
- Winkl make two mattresses where Ecosa make one
- Winkl is rated a medium firmness, which will be universally comfortable. Ecosa is rated 7-8, and is definitely firmer. My experience of Ecosa is it’s firmer than I personally like, but it’s comfortable enough that I sleep well on it anyway
- Ecosa has interchangeable layers inside it’s mattress to adjust the firmness. Both Winkl mattresses are around the same firmness
- Winkl customer service are a lot easier to get hold of than Ecosa (I find Ecosa quite slow to respond to queries, Winkl respond within hours, even on weekends)
- Ecosa has two covers on their mattress: there is an internal waterproof cover
- Winkl mattresses contain thicker layers of comfort foams than the Ecosa mattress
- Ecosa has more sizes available (full breakdown of sizes further on in article)
Close-Up On Their Construction
Here’s a detailed breakdown of the construction of each mattress. I’ll show you the one Ecosa mattress and both Winkl mattresses.
Ecosa is a 25 cm high mattress with 3 internal layers. This is pretty much standard across many mattresses in boxes,both here and internationally. One of the things that really drew us to the Ecosa mattress when we were deciding what to purchase was the fact that you can adjust the firmness level by changing around the layers inside the mattress. This clever design allows Ecosa to make just the one mattress to suit different people. However, even with the softer layer at the top it’s still pretty firm.
The cover of the Ecosa mattress actually has two layers:
- The removable, breathable outer which is machine washable
- The waterproof and dust mite repelling inner cover (also removable so you can switch the mattress layers around as desired)
The first two layers are your comfort foams.The third layer is the support core layer, but if you want to sleep on a really firm feeling mattress you can move this layer to the top (you’ll read why you shouldn’t just flip it over in the foam description).
- The blue layer is named “G-7”, and is a gel memory foam. Gel memory foam is known for its cooling properties. This layer is 3cm thick. Keep this layer on the top of the mattress for the “softest” feel this mattress can give you (remember, it’s not soft! It’s still very firm to me!). This is how we have our own Ecosa mattress configured.
- The white layer is a memory foam that Ecosa have designed themselves. Called Eco-Tex, this foam is designed to mimic the feel of latex (which is known for it’s cooling, durability, and bounce). This layer is 4cm thick, which means the two comfort layers combined make up 7cm of the 25cm total. Put the white layer on the top of your mattress to give it an even firmer feel!
- The largest section of the mattress is the high density support foam, made from plant based polyurethane. It makes up about 7 inches of the mattress height. This layer is what you would put at the top of the mattress if you wanted it to feel like a rock. Ecosa is actually the first company I’ve seen suggesting you sleep directly on this polyfoam layer, but the airflow convolutions make it feasible. The convolutions will also allow further contouring support. (The convolutions are the reason you shouldn’t just flip your Ecosa, if you decide to try out sleeping directly on this layer, you need them at the top for airflow.)
The standard Winkl mattress 25cm high, same as Ecosa. You can’t change your foam layers around inside Winkl, but with its softer feel without compromising on support, it’s designed for a wide range of people to sleep comfortably on.
Removable and breathable.
As with Ecosa, Winkl contains three internal foam layers that is 25cm high. The two comfort foam layers at the top make up a total of 10cm, so you’re getting more comfort foam in your Winkl.
- The light purple layer is a foam exclusive to Winkl. It’s been designed to have a bit of bounce like a latex foam. This helps you to feel supported on the mattress without feeling like you’re sinking into it or getting stuck in it.
- The dark purple layer is a high density gel foam. I really like this layer because I see so many overseas companies using a lower density (read: lower durability) foam for this layer which leads to sagging. The fact that it’s high density means the inclusion of the gel infusion is important to help keep you cool (gel beads draw heat out of the foam) because high density foams are not as good at letting air flow through them as their lower density, open cell counterparts.
- High density support foam. Pretty standard, there’s not much more to say here.
The Winkl Lux is also a 3 layer foam construction, but it’s 30cm high. The two foam comfort layers make up 13cm of the total mattress height (this is nearly double the amount of comfort foam found in Ecosa).
It features quite a few luxury upgrades over the Winkl, as the name suggests. For your extra $ you get a thicker mattress that has more foam in the comfort layers, charcoal infused into the memory foam and zoning in the support foam. Basically, the Lux lives up to its name: it’s a high performing mattress with lots of great features and technology whereas the standard Winkl is a decent mattress with less bling.
This is one of the upgrades over the standard Winkl mattress. It is a more luxurious knit. It’s softer and more durable.
- The top layer is the same proprietary Winkl-flex foam you find in the standard model, but there’s more of it in the Lux.
- The transtiion layer has been infused with charcoal instead of gel. This is a less common feature, but a really good one because not only will it help with temerature regulation, it’s also antimicrobial.
- The base foam in the Winkl Lux has been divided into zones for targeted support. This is a really nice luxury touch, and something I see overseas brands charge a fortune for. The zones are designed to be more forgiving for your shoulders and hips and firmer through the centre to help support your spine.
For More Detailed Comparison Of The Winkl And The Winkl Lux, Please Read My Winkl Mattress Review Here.
|Single||91 x 188 x 25||92 x 188 x 25
92 x 188 x 30 (Lux)
|Long Single||91 x 203 x 25||-|
|King Single||107x 203 x 25||107 x 203 x 25
107 x 203 x 30 (Lux)
|Double||137 x 188 x 25||138 x 188 x 25
138 x 188 x 30 (Lux)
|Queen||153 x 203 x 25||152 x 203 x 25
152 x 203 x 30 (Lux)
|King||167 x 203 x 25||168 x 203 x 25
168 x 203 x 30
|Super King||183 x 203 x 25||183 x 203 x 25
183 x 203 x 30 (Lux)
|California King||203 x 203 x 25||-|
Feel And Firmness
As mentioned above, Winkl is a medium feel. This is softer than the Ecosa, and is more universally appealing. There are a few things to consider here though, as it’s not as simple as that so here are some scenarios where one mattress might suit you better than the other:
- You’re not sure what firmness you want
- You share a bed with someone who likes a different firmness than you. Winkl is probably going to be a better compromise
- You like to sleep on your side: Winkl will give you more pressure relief through your shoulder
- You want a firm mattress (this was my husband. This is why we ended up with Ecosa)
- You like to sleep on your stomach: a firmer mattress will be better for your spine because it will have more support through your hips
- You weigh more than 150kg: you need a firm mattress to give you adequate support. Interestingly, if you buy a softer mattress, it can end up feeling too hard because you sink through the comfort layers and feel the support core of the mattress – this isn’t what you want, you want to feel well supported
The good news is that I think both work well for people who mainly sleep on their back, it will come down to personal firmness preference and other factors (like if you want to buy NZ owned or the sleep trial length, or warranty length). Remember, whichever one you choose, you’ve got more than 3 months to try it out at home.
The prices listed below are RRP. You should note that mattress-in-box companies always have a deal going. My links will take you to the deal, never pay full retail!
Winkl Vs Ecosa: Which Is Better?
Like most things in life, there is no black and white answer for Winkl Vs Ecosa. It all depends on what you want from your mattress! I hope I’ve helped you understand the differences between the two and it’s easier for you to make a decision.
What I will say is that if I needed to buy another mattress, I’d buy Winkl over Ecosa. The main reason for this is because it’s that bit softer, which would work well for me. I really like the features Winkl have incorporated into their Lux mattress, so I’d choose that model. I also like the fact they are New Zealand owned and you get fast responses from their New Zealand based support team.